Gail Russell and John Wayne: What killed her is beyond tragic

Gail Russell was a hauntingly beautiful Hollywood starlet, known for her large, gorgeous blue eyes

But despite her grace, the talented actress struggled behind the scenes.

And the circumstances surrounding her final days remain a haunting tragedy…

Hollywood star Gail Russell is best remembered for playing John Wayne‘s love interest in the 1947 Western The Angel and the Badman.

The young actress, with her dark hair and an aura of quiet grace, portrayed a Quaker girl who transforms John Wayne’s character, a hardened gunfighter, into a peaceful man.

Their on-screen chemistry quickly fueled rumors of a real-life romance, but to fully grasp Gail Russell’s tragic end, we must trace her roots back to her childhood. It’s a story of how a shy high schooler rose from relative obscurity to become one of Paramount Studios’ brightest stars of the 1940s.

Painfully shy

Gail Russell was born in Chicago in 1924 and moved to Los Angeles with her parents at the age of 14. Her father, a musician, kept a piano at home — but it served a very different purpose in the Russell household.

Since Gail was extremely shy from a young age, she would often run and hide under the piano whenever her parents had guests. Despite her timidity, with her striking dark blue eyes and stunning looks, it seemed Gail was destined for something special. It wasn’t acting that first stood out, though — it was her talent for painting. The Windy City native began drawing at the age of five, and most who saw her artwork agreed she was exceptionally gifted.

”Dad used to tell me that I could be anything, anything I wanted to be, but I thought he was saying that because he loved me,” Gail once said.

As a young girl growing up during the Great Depression, she dreamed of becoming a commercial artist. But as a teenager, her mother convinced her to pursue a film career instead. In fact, her mother’s ambitions for Gail were one of the reasons the family relocated to California when she was 14.

Gail attended Santa Monica High School, where she earned the nickname “the Hedy Lamarr of Santa Monica.” After graduating, she quickly signed a long-term contract with Paramount Pictures, earning $50 a week.

Cinderella story

The story of how Gail Russell was discovered by Hollywood has a bit of a Cinderella flair. According to the biography Gail Russell: A Fallen Star, William Meiklejohn, then head of talent at Paramount Pictures, was driving home from San Diego along the Pacific Highway when he spotted two teenage boys hitchhiking. They seemed to be in good spirits, so Meiklejohn decided to give them a ride.

One of the boys soon noticed a Paramount sticker on the car, and the trio started chatting about his job as a talent scout in Hollywood. Meiklejohn boasted about working with beautiful stars like Dorothy Lamour, Paulette Goddard, and Veronica Lake. That’s when the boys mentioned a girl from their school — Gail Russell — whom they described as ”the prettiest girl you’ll ever see.” Intrigued yet skeptical, Meiklejohn listened closely.

”No kidding, Mister. You ought to see this girl. She’s the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen. She ought to be in the movies. No kidding. Not only is she beautiful, but when she starts walking, wow, what a voice! Every boy in Santa Monica Tech is turning handsprings just to get her to look at them,” one of the boys, Charlie Cates, said.

Meiklejohn, always on the lookout for new and beautiful actresses, was persuaded by the boys’ enthusiastic recommendations and decided to seek out Gail. At just 18, the shy young woman found herself thrust into the lion’s den of Hollywood.

As she later recalled, ”Everything happened so fast. I was going to high school and the next thing I knew I was being groomed for a picture. There was this terrific mountain of work and no time to catch up with myself,” Gail said.

Crying on set

Early in her career, Gail Russell found success, particularly with The Uninvited, directed by Lewis Allen. However, working with the young actress wasn’t always easy. Producer Charles Brackett shared stories of what went on behind the scenes.

He recalled how Gail would cry on set, often with her mother by her side, claiming she had a sore throat. In reality, she was upset because director Lewis Allen had insisted she wear a hat for a scene, something she strongly resisted.

”She could only do about five or six lines, and then she’d burst into tears,” Brackett explained.

Her co-stars and crew tried to help Gail overcome her overwhelming timidity, but her nerves never fully eased. Instead, the star began self-medicating with alcohol to calm herself, a habit that would have devastating consequences. Apparently, it was the head of makeup on set who first suggested she turn to alcohol.

Gail Russell had the looks of a classic movie star, but tragically, she lacked the temperament to match. She struggled with stage fright and had a deep aversion to public speaking. In one of her rare interviews with Helen Weller, Russell opened up about her extreme shyness, shedding light on the personal challenges that plagued her career.

”I can’t remember the time I wasn’t painfully shy. I don’t mean the garden variety shyness most people have. Mine was thousands times worse. I was possessed with an agonizing kind of self-consciousness where I felt my insides tightening into a knot, where my face and hands grew clammy, where I couldn’t open my mouth, where I fel impelled to turn and run if I had to meet new people,” the actress shared.

John Wayne love affair

During the filming of Angel and the Badman, Gail Russell reportedly developed feelings for her co-star, the legendary John Wayne. According to sources like jwayne.fan.com, her feelings were not answered, but Wayne went out of his way to support Gail. Wayne asked his secretary, Mary St. John, to gently explain his feelings to Gail. ”Set Gail straight. Make sure she understands how I feel, but do it gently,” he told St. John. ”The poor kid’s having a tough time.”

Unlike many in the industry, Wayne showed Gail a rare level of respect and kindness, something she seldom experienced from other leading men or producers

The two became close friends on set, with Wayne acting as a protective figure. He recognized a vulnerability in Gail that others might have exploited, becoming almost a father figure to her.

Gail’s feelings soon faded and there’s no evidence of a romantic relationship between them. However, John Wayne’s second wife, Esperanza “Chata” Bauer, thought otherwise. Their marriage, famously described as ”like shaking two volatile chemicals in a jar,” didn’t need much to ignite.

The Mexican actress was convinced her husband was having an affair with Gail during the shooting of Angel and the Badman. Chata’s suspicion escalated when Wayne came home late after a wrap party celebrating the end of the movie.

The actor was nearly shot by Chata on their doorstep.

”My wife refused to let me in. I could hear her and her mother talking about me loudly. I rang the bell but they wouldn’t open the door. Then I broke a glass panel, reached in, and opened it myself. Chata and her mother came charging out. Chata had a forty-five in her hand. She and her mother were fighting over it,” Wayne testified in court, according to Daily Express.

Getting arrested

By the early 1950s, Gail Russell’s struggle with alcohol was no longer a secret. While those who worked with her were aware of her issues, it soon became public knowledge. In November 1953, she was arrested and convicted of drunk driving. She was sentenced to two years’ probation on the condition that she refrain from alcohol, avoid places where it was served, and seek medical treatment. Additionally, she was fined $150.

That same year, during John Wayne’s divorce proceedings, his then-wife Chata claimed that Wayne and Russell had spent the night together. Adding to the turmoil, Gail herself was in the middle of divorcing her husband, actor Guy Madison.

Her life was spiraling downhill, and after falling into a coma due to a severe bout of hepatitis, she was hospitalized multiple times, moving in and out of sanatoriums.

Unfortunately, it didn’t take long after her release from the hospital for Gail to find herself back behind the wheel under the influence. This time, she was involved in a serious accident, crashing into a couple and their baby. Once again, she was fined and faced a lawsuit from the family.

Paramount Pictures dumped her, and Gail’s career faced a sharp decline, leaving her to take on a string of unremarkable roles. Despite her long-standing issues, her old friend John Wayne tried to lend a helping hand by securing her a part in Seven Men From Now (1956), alongside Lee Marvin and Randolph Scott.

However, the years of mental health struggles and alcohol abuse had taken their toll — Gail looked far older than her age. Despite taking on sporadic roles, it became clear that major studios no longer wanted much to do with her.

She continued to face legal trouble for driving under the influence but couldn’t let go of her passion for acting.

”I guess there are still a lot of doubts about me”, the actress said in April 1960. “And this is one of the reasons why I want to get back to the business to prove to people I can do a picture. I’m stronger now. The future looks pretty good.”

Cause of death

By the end of her life, Gail had retreated from the public eye and lived in a small house under the name Moseley, distancing herself from her Hollywood past.

She continued to struggle with alcoholism, which had plagued her for years.

In August 1961, she was found dead in her Brentwood, Los Angeles home. Two neighbors, concerned after not hearing from her for several days, discovered her body on the floor. An empty vodka bottle lay beside her, and the house was littered with more empty bottles. She was just 36 years old.

The autopsy revealed that Gail died from liver damage caused by acute and chronic alcoholism. She was also suffering from malnutrition at the time of her death.

One of the neighbors who found Gail, Virginia Darnell, told AP that the actress had only lived in the house for a few months and had no visitors during that time. Inside, several of Gail’s paintings were discovered —landscapes, animals— showing that she had returned to her first passion, painting.

It was something she had dreamed of as a young girl, and perhaps, in a different life, that’s what she was meant to do. But fate had other plans, and now we all know how her story tragically ended.

Thank you for the memories on the silver screen, Gail Russell!

It’s heartbreaking that you didn’t always get the help you needed, but times were different, and perhaps you couldn’t face your own struggles.

Still, we remember a stunningly beautiful and talented actress who earned her place in Hollywood’s history. Rest in peace, Gail.